Buy The Battle for Spain: The Spanish Civil War Digital original by Antony Beevor (ISBN: ) from Amazon’s Book Store. Everyday low. Homage to Catalonia by George Orwell For Whom the Bell Tolls by Ernest Hemingway The Battle for Spain by Antony Beevor The Assassin’s Mark by David . A fresh and acclaimed account of the Spanish Civil War by the bestselling author the 70th anniversary of the Spanish Civil War’s outbreak, Antony Beevor has.
|Published (Last):||9 August 2008|
|PDF File Size:||10.33 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||13.13 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
The Battle for Spain by Antony Beevor | : Books
Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. Obviously it was time for someone to write a book beevorr this cock-eyed view. Among the victims were wntony, clergy and nuns. We are meant to be discussing his latest book, The Battle for Spain, an epic history of the Spanish Civil War that has topped the Spanish book charts, unleashing a storm of debate, but a question about history in schools has touched a nerve.
First published init was regarded as a competent but not especially original account of the war.
Review: The Battle for Spain by Antony Beevor | Books | The Guardian
Although the book is harrowing, given the human tragedy, the fact that Juan Carlos, hand-picked by Franco to rule as a royal dictator, moved the country rapidly towards full democracy, provides a profoundly satisfying conclusion. There are only some bland maps at the start of the book.
Undersupplied by their allies, undermined by their political leaders and untrained they were always on the back foot. I had hoped that the history of the Spanish Civil might help me to better understand the forces at work in the Syrian Civil War, another proxy war against terrorized civilians, who are trapped or made refugees by implacable hate and stupefying local factionalism and whose agony meets with the indifferent yawn of contemporaries afforded the luxury of being out of range.
Beevor incorporates research made available only after the fall of the Soviet Union, which fought on the side of the Republicans, but he fails to adequately summarize so many facts piled upon facts, stacked like stolid towers of encyclopedias.
Most soldiers did not know the extent of Stalinist penetration of their upper ranks, let alone the detailed plans to liquidate their anarchist, Trotskyist, socialist and liberal comrades-in-arms the moment that victory was won. Both sides hardened their positions, with the generals leading military assaults designed to expand their territory. It’s akin to watching a train heading into the abyss, you know where it’s going, you wanted it to change for the better and the rational part of you knows that it wasn’t going to happen.
The Asturias Rising of Octoberin which up to 30, miners attacked the Civil Guard and public buildings and assaulted a military garrison of 1, soldiers, was nothing less than an attempted provincial revolution. Authority without equality, power without justice. The grand sweep of the narrative is obscured.
The Battle for Spain: The Spanish Civil War 1936-1939
El primero es preferable moralmente y totalmente inadecuado en sus medios; y el segundo usa medios eficaces para cumplir objetivos injustos.
Whereas he first said that 1, people were killed at Guernica, he now says between and Jul 29, Dachokie rated it liked it Shelves: Good not only beevog the battle fronts but the social context and the plotting and posturing.
I certainly learned a lot from this book, but I’m also certain that I still could not What a depressingly confusing and unmitigated mess human history can be. Oct 20, Marius van Blerck rated it really liked it.
After briefly chronicling the fall antont Spain’s reactionary monarchy and the turbulent, anarchic history of its Second Republic, Beevor turns to the Army’s attempted sppain of Julya right-wing response to the election of a socialist-communist government earlier that year. Spanish workers and anarchists also quickly organized pro-government militias, which allowed the loyalists to retain control of the capital and most of Spain’s outlying provinces.
One might expect a historian of the Second World War to treat the Spanish conflict as a prologue to that larger and deadlier global struggle, but Beevor sees that the civil war had great significance in its own right.
A war for opportunists Filed: This internal convulsion did more to ensure Franco’s victory than his own unimaginative generalship.
Franco and Salazar would terrorize fod stagnate the Iberian peninsula long after Hitler and Mussolini’s eviction; bedvor read The Battle for SpainI couldn’t care less. One thing that repeatedly struck me as I read through this book was the contrast in efficiency between the nationalists and the republicans.
This war was caused by a perfect storm of po The Spanish Civil War…Brought to you by the same people who gave us the Inquisition.
The Battle for Spain
Gor left behind found themselves in a country almost paralysed by entrenched and irreconcilable beliefs: It told a chronological, nuts-and-bolts story that held the reader’s attention.
Other documents show how the Anyony reserved the best military kit and medical care for their own forces, while charging the republic a fortune for weapons bahtle other services. After the war, the Nationalists used thetoRepublican prisoners as slave labor. Thus we see the nationalist army consolidating itself under Franco, while the republican side devolved into warring factions, more concerned with their utopian schemes than with winning the war.
The British Government adopted the policy of non-intervention, partly so as not to irritate Hitler and Mussolini, but principally because of its fear of Communism.
This is not a level of detail I want, or need, to know.
The Spanish Civil War London: